Benny Blanco and Selena Gomez: Unraveling the Cheating Rumor Frenzy
In a whirlwind of gossip that has set social media ablaze, music producer Benny Blanco has found himself at the center of a storm, with rumors swirling that he confessed to cheating on his fiancée, pop superstar Selena Gomez, with the damning admission, “I messed up.” The speculation, which erupted after Blanco was spotted dining with Gomez’s longtime friend Theresa Marie in Los Angeles, has sent fans into a frenzy, dissecting every Instagram post and TikTok video for clues. Yet, as the dust settles, it’s becoming clear that the narrative of betrayal may be more fiction than fact, fueled by internet sleuths and a misunderstanding that Gomez herself has subtly debunked. This saga, blending love, friendship, and the power of social media, is a testament to the chaos that can erupt when celebrity lives collide with public scrutiny.
The Spark That Ignited the Rumor
The drama began on March 24, 2025, when Blanco was spotted at a Los Angeles restaurant with Theresa Marie, a close friend and former assistant to Gomez. The moment was captured in a viral TikTok video by content creator Harry Daniels, who is known for approaching celebrities and serenading them with their own songs. In the clip, Daniels sang Gomez’s hit “Same Old Love”—which Blanco co-wrote and produced—while Blanco laughed and quipped, “Are you just following me at this point?” Daniels replied, “I want to be at the wedding,” a playful nod to Blanco and Gomez’s engagement, announced in December 2024. The video, which garnered over 2.4 million likes, seemed innocuous at first. But fans quickly noticed that Gomez was absent from the scene, and speculation about a “secret date” between Blanco and Marie took off.
The rumor gained traction when eagle-eyed followers pointed out that Gomez had unfollowed Marie on Instagram around the same time. For a fandom accustomed to decoding social media moves, this was tantamount to a declaration of war. Theories multiplied: Had Blanco betrayed Gomez with her best friend? Was the unfollow a sign of a deeper rift? Some even claimed Blanco had subscribed to Marie’s OnlyFans account, though no credible evidence supported this. The narrative escalated with whispers that Blanco had confessed to infidelity, allegedly saying, “I messed up,” though no verifiable source has confirmed such a statement. The internet, ever eager for drama, ran with the story, turning a casual dinner into a full-blown scandal.
Selena Gomez’s Subtle Rebuttal
In true Gomez fashion, the pop star chose not to engage directly with the rumors, opting instead for a strategic social media move that spoke volumes. On May 7, 2025, she posted an Instagram carousel captioned, “Lil blast from the past because basically I’m lying horizontal rn and reminiscing bout some memories.” The post featured a series of throwback photos, including a prominent snap with Theresa Marie, signaling that their friendship remained intact. Other images included a framed photo with Taylor Swift from the 1989 World Tour and a shot of Gomez’s sister, Gracie, underscoring a nostalgic, unbothered vibe. The inclusion of Marie in the post was widely interpreted as a quiet rebuttal to the cheating allegations, with fans praising Gomez for shutting down the gossip without fueling the fire.
The timing of the post was no coincidence. Just days earlier, the rumor mill had reached fever pitch, with social media platforms buzzing with hashtags and theories. Gomez’s decision to highlight her bond with Marie, coupled with a subsequent Instagram Story showing Blanco playing with their family dog and his nephew, sent a clear message: all was well in her world. Blanco, for his part, continued to follow both Gomez and Marie on Instagram, and Marie liked posts related to the couple’s joint album, I Said I Love You First, released in March 2025. These small but deliberate actions suggested that the trio was unaffected by the speculation, leaving many to wonder how the rumor had spiraled so far.
A Love Story Under Scrutiny
To understand the intensity of this controversy, it’s worth revisiting the romance between Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco. The couple, who first collaborated on tracks like “I Can’t Get Enough” in 2019, began dating in 2023 after years of friendship. Their relationship went public in December 2023, when Gomez confirmed they were together, and by December 2024, Blanco had proposed, sharing the moment with fans on social media. Their engagement, marked by sweet gestures and public displays of affection, was celebrated by fans who saw Gomez, a veteran of high-profile romances and personal struggles, finally finding stability.
The couple’s joint album, I Said I Love You First, was a musical love letter, documenting their journey from friends to fiancés. Tracks like the deluxe version’s I Said I Love You First…And You Said It Back resonated with fans, who admired the couple’s chemistry both on and off the stage. Yet, their happiness has not shielded them from scrutiny. Gomez, whose past relationships—most notably with Justin Bieber—have been dissected relentlessly, is no stranger to public speculation. Blanco, a Grammy-nominated producer known for hits with artists like Rihanna and Ed Sheeran, has also faced criticism, with some fans questioning his motives or mocking his quirky persona.
The Role of Theresa Marie
Central to the rumor is Theresa Marie, a figure who has been a fixture in Gomez’s life for over a decade. Marie, a businesswoman and OnlyFans creator, started as Gomez’s assistant in 2014 and quickly became a trusted confidante. In 2019, the pair launched Krahs Swim, a swimwear brand rooted in empowerment, and Gomez has frequently praised Marie’s strength and positivity. In a heartfelt Instagram post from 2019, Gomez wrote, “I met Theresa 5 years ago. We worked together and became best friends. She has taught me how to see life in a fun, carefree, and uplifting way.” Their bond, evident in countless photos from beach trips to hospital visits, made the idea of a fallout—let alone one involving Blanco—particularly shocking.
The speculation about Marie’s role in the alleged scandal was amplified by her public persona. As an OnlyFans creator, she has faced scrutiny from some fans who viewed her online activity as incompatible with Gomez’s wholesome image. However, there’s no evidence that Marie’s career has strained her friendship with Gomez, and her continued engagement with Gomez’s content suggests loyalty. The dinner with Blanco, far from a clandestine affair, could have been a casual catch-up, possibly related to their shared connection to Gomez. Yet, in the absence of context, fans filled the gap with their own narratives, turning a mundane moment into a soap opera.
The Power of Social Media Sleuthing
This saga underscores the outsized role of social media in shaping celebrity narratives. Platforms like TikTok and X have become breeding grounds for speculation, where a single video or unfollow can spark a global controversy. The Harry Daniels TikTok, while intended as lighthearted content, became a catalyst for chaos, with fans dissecting Blanco’s body language and Marie’s presence for signs of guilt. Comments like “Benny looks like he’s STRUGGLING” and “You just ended the wedding!” fueled the narrative, despite lacking any substantive proof. Similarly, X users debated the significance of Gomez’s unfollow, with some calling the rumors “baseless” while others insisted there was “more to the story.”
The phenomenon of “internet sleuthing” is not new, but its impact on celebrities like Gomez is profound. Fans, protective of Gomez after her well-documented struggles with health and heartbreak, are quick to rally against perceived threats. Blanco, as an outsider to Gomez’s inner circle, has faced particular skepticism, with some labeling him “tasteless” for sharing personal anecdotes about their relationship, like Gomez’s nervous habits during their early dates. These criticisms, while often rooted in loyalty to Gomez, highlight the double-edged sword of fame: every move is scrutinized, and every rumor amplified.
A Broader Cultural Context
The Blanco-Gomez rumor mill reflects broader themes in pop culture, where celebrity relationships are both idolized and torn apart. Gomez, a former Disney star turned mental health advocate, occupies a unique space in the public imagination. Her resilience through lupus, public breakups, and media scrutiny has earned her a devoted fanbase, but it also makes her a target for sensationalism. The cheating rumors, though unproven, tap into a narrative of betrayal that resonates with fans who’ve followed her romantic journey.
Moreover, the controversy highlights the gendered dynamics of gossip. Gomez’s decision to address the rumors indirectly, through curated posts rather than confrontation, aligns with her reputation for grace under pressure. Blanco, meanwhile, has faced harsher judgment, with some fans questioning his worthiness of Gomez. The scrutiny of Marie, particularly her OnlyFans career, also reveals biases about women’s autonomy and public personas. In a sense, this rumor is less about infidelity and more about the expectations placed on celebrities to perform perfection.
Moving Forward
As of May 2025, Gomez and Blanco appear to be weathering the storm. Their social media activity, from joint album promotions to affectionate posts, suggests a relationship undeterred by gossip. Gomez’s inclusion of Marie in her Instagram post has quelled much of the speculation, though questions linger about why she unfollowed her friend in the first place. It’s possible the unfollow was unrelated to Blanco, perhaps a personal or professional decision that fans misread. Without a direct statement from the trio, the truth remains elusive, but their actions speak to a desire to move past the drama.
For Gomez, this is just another chapter in a career defined by resilience. Her ability to navigate rumors with poise, while continuing to build her empire through Rare Beauty and Only Murders in the Building, is a testament to her strength. Blanco, too, seems committed to their future, with plans for a wedding and possibly a family, as hinted in recent interviews. Marie, a quieter figure, continues to support Gomez from the sidelines, her loyalty evident despite the online chatter.
A Rumor That Never Was
The tale of Benny Blanco’s alleged “I messed up” confession is a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked speculation. What began as a lighthearted TikTok morphed into a narrative of betrayal, fueled by assumptions and amplified by social media. Yet, through it all, Gomez, Blanco, and Marie have shown that relationships—romantic and platonic—can withstand the noise. As fans continue to dissect their every move, one thing is clear: this Hollywood love story is far from over, and its next chapter promises to be just as captivating. So, scroll through the posts, unpack the drama, and see why this rumor has everyone buzzing.
