🚨 TOWERING KNIGHT ALERT: Peter Claffey is ABSOLUTELY MASSIVE as Ser Duncan the Tall – But Does He Match the LEGENDARY Book Giant? Fans Are Divided! 🚨

Read more:

The HBO series A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, which debuted in January 2026, has thrust viewers back into the world of Westeros with a fresh take on George R.R. Martin’s Dunk and Egg tales. At the center of the story stands Ser Duncan the Tall, the hedge knight whose physical stature is as much a part of his character as his sense of honor. Played by Irish actor Peter Claffey, Dunk arrives on screen as an imposing figure, but questions linger about how closely the portrayal aligns with the immense scale described in Martin’s novellas.

In the original Dunk and Egg stories—The Hedge Knight, The Sworn Sword, and The Mystery Knight—Ser Duncan is portrayed as extraordinarily tall. George R.R. Martin describes him as “an inch shy of seven feet,” placing the character at roughly 6 feet 11 inches. This height is no minor detail; it’s woven into the narrative. Dunk struggles to find fitting armor, towers over opponents during tournaments, and draws constant remarks from other characters about his size. One memorable line has a figure telling him, “The Seven above gave you tallness. So be tall.” The books use this trait to emphasize Dunk’s outsider status—a lowborn knight whose sheer physical presence sets him apart in a world of scheming lords and armored warriors.

Peter Claffey, the actor embodying Dunk, brings his own considerable build to the role. A former rugby union player from Portumna, County Galway, Ireland, Claffey stands at 6 feet 5 inches tall, with a broad, athletic frame honed from years on the field. Before transitioning to acting, he competed at a notable level, including time with Connacht Rugby and Ireland’s U20 team. His screen credits prior to this breakout include appearances in Vikings: Valhalla, Wreck, and Bad Sisters. When HBO announced the casting in April 2024, producers highlighted a global search for actors “over 6-foot-5” in the appropriate age range, underscoring the challenge of finding someone who could convincingly portray such a large character while handling the physical demands of swordplay, horseback riding, and extended shoots in heavy armor.

The gap between Claffey’s real height and the book’s description amounts to about six inches. In practical terms, achieving an exact 6’11” match would have been difficult—few actors of that stature fit the young, rugged profile needed for Dunk at the start of his journey. Production opted for visual techniques to amplify the illusion of greater height. Cinematography employs low-angle shots to make Claffey loom larger, wide framing contrasts him against smaller co-stars like Dexter Sol Ansell as Egg, and the armor design features exaggerated proportions to broaden his silhouette. In scenes where Dunk interacts with horses or stands in doorways, the effect is pronounced—he appears to fill the space in a way that echoes the book’s descriptions.

Executive producer Ira Parker addressed the approach in interviews around the premiere, explaining that the team prioritized finding the tallest capable actor in his late 20s who could perform the role’s rigors. “The book character is 6-foot-11,” Parker noted, “but we were looking for as tall as possible in that age range.” Claffey, at 6’5″, met the criteria and has been praised for how “massive” he looks on screen. His rugby background provided the strength and coordination required for tourney sequences, while his natural build helps sell Dunk’s gentle-giant persona—earnest, somewhat awkward, yet undeniably formidable.

Fan reactions have been mixed but largely favorable. Many viewers point out that Claffey “feels” as tall as needed through the show’s clever staging. Side-by-side comparisons with Egg highlight the disparity, and moments where Dunk nearly bumps his head or dwarfs his mount reinforce the giant-like impression. Social media has seen praise for the performance, with comments noting that the actor’s presence carries the legend even without an exact height match. Some book purists have expressed mild disappointment over the shortfall, arguing it slightly diminishes the overwhelming physicality Martin intended. However, the consensus among most audiences is that the series effectively conveys Dunk’s stature as a defining trait.

This isn’t the first instance where the Game of Thrones franchise has adjusted physical details for casting practicality. The original series featured actors whose heights were close but not identical to their book counterparts—Rory McCann as The Hound (around 6’6″) and Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson as The Mountain (over 6’9″) come to mind. In each case, performance and production design bridged any gaps. Similarly, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms relies on Claffey’s commanding screen presence to make Dunk believable as the towering hedge knight.

Claffey has spoken about embracing the role’s challenges, from the weight of plate armor to portraying a man whose size often works against him in subtle ways. His performance captures Dunk’s humility and quiet strength, qualities that define the character beyond mere measurements. The series’ focus remains on Dunk’s moral journey, his bond with Egg, and the smaller-scale intrigues of the era, rather than relying solely on height for drama.

As the show builds toward key events like the Trial of Seven, Dunk’s physicality will continue to play a role in battles and confrontations. Whether Claffey’s portrayal fully replicates the book’s near-mythical scale is debatable, but it has succeeded in making Ser Duncan the Tall feel larger than life on screen. For a franchise known for its epic scope, the choice reflects a balance between source fidelity and real-world feasibility.

In the end, Peter Claffey’s Dunk stands tall—literally and figuratively—delivering a hedge knight whose presence commands attention. While not every inch matches Martin’s exact vision, the spirit of the towering, honorable warrior shines through, proving that sometimes screen magic can make even legends feel real.