🔥 Everyone said they hated him… until now. He’s BACK — and fans are losing it. 😱

He was the most divisive character in Season 1 of Nobody Wants This.
Loved? No.
Memorable? Absolutely.And now he’s returning — confirmed — for a bigger role in Season 2.

Netflix’s Nobody Wants This season 2 will bring back two of the most important supporting characters who can fix a Joanne problem from season 1. The romantic comedy Nobody Wants This took the world by storm when it was first released at the end of 2024, and fans have waited anxiously for news about the next season. Now that Nobody Wants This season 2 has wrapped filming (with Jackie Tohn sharing BTS photos!), fans can start looking ahead to the new season, which is expected to be released around September 2025.

I can’t wait to see how Joanne and Noah navigate their relationship now that their careers are pulling them in opposite directions. Most of the attention from fans and the narrative goes towards how Joanne will impact Noah’s job prospects and family. It’s unclear, based on Nobody Wants This season 1’s ending, how their relationship will affect the Head Rabbi promotion that he agreed to pursue. However, Joanne deserves just as much attention when it comes to her podcasting career. Luckily, two essential returning supporting characters will fix the issue by giving Joanne the support and attention that she needs.

Ashley & Ryann Are The Two Most Important Returning Supporting Characters In Nobody Wants This Season 2

Ashley & Ryann Are The Only Supporting Characters On Joanne’s Side

As much as I love Nobody Wants This, season 1 has one big problem – it feels unbalanced. Most of the main and supporting characters in Nobody Wants This, except for Morgan, are Noah’s friends and family. Esther and Sasha are both main characters in the story, and they connect to Noah. The supporting characters Miriam, Rebecca, Rabbi Cohen, and Rabbi Shira have a connection to him as well. Joanne tries to develop a relationship with his colleagues, his friends, and their wives. She tries really hard to join his world and changes parts of herself to fit into his culture.

✕Remove Ads

Unfortunately, he spends less time with her friends. He listens to her podcast to try to understand her job and perspective, but he doesn’t give much thought to how he fits in her world. Even Joanne’s parents have a significantly smaller role than Noah’s parents. In a way, the decision to focus on Noah’s family and friends makes sense because his community is much more hesitant of Joanne, while Joanne’s secular community is more willing to accept Noah (although some of them really don’t understand Judaism). There’s less conflict on her side of the relationship.

Ultimately, the imbalance means Nobody Wants This season 2 bringing back the few supporting characters on Joanne’s side is extremely important. Ashley and Ryann help balance out the cast so that Noah and Joanne are both represented as main characters rather than the story being entirely one-sided. Additionally, the duo coming back in the second season means that Noah and Joanne might spend some more time with her social circle, too.

Joanne Will Need Her Friends To Ground Her As She Explores Converting To Judaism In Nobody Wants This

Possibly Converting Will Be A Big Decision For Joanne Now That She Knows The Stakes

Although they were significant before, Joanne’s friendships will be even more important in Nobody Wants This season 2 as she’s giving more serious consideration to whether or not she could ever be ready to convert. After her conversation with Rebecca, she now understands what being the Rabbi’s girlfriend or wife would mean. It’s a lot of responsibility. She doesn’t seem entirely closed off to the idea of converting one day, but she knows that she isn’t there yet. That means she needs people outside the situation to talk to about her thoughts and feelings.

Since the Netflix rom-com is semi-autobiographical (via Y! Entertainment), I expect that Joanne will eventually convert, like the creator of the show (though that’s not a guaranteed ending for the character). I’m not sure that decision will come by the end of Nobody Wants This season 2 with how far she has to go in learning about Judaism and examining her own beliefs.

Joanne might also face more pressure to convert now that Noah has agreed to pursue the Head Rabbi job at the end of Nobody Wants This season 1, which could influence her feelings on the matter. Unfortunately, Noah and Joanne told other people about the decision at Miriam’s Bat Mitzvah, making it even harder to walk back. On the off chance that people don’t pressure her to convert, she will almost definitely face judgment from the Roklovs and other members of the temple for having changed her mind about converting.