Stranger Things Season 5 just gutted its sweetest new romance… and fans are furious 💔😡

Robin and Vickie were the fresh, heartfelt spark we needed in an otherwise chaotic final season—awkward crushes turning into real connection, queer rep that felt earned after Robin’s Season 4 confession, steamy moments amid the monster chaos, and that hopeful vibe of two girls finally figuring it out in ’80s Hawkins. It was one of the few bright spots in a season full of plot holes, rushed arcs, and safe choices.

Full story:

The dust has barely settled on Stranger Things’ epic series finale, which dropped on New Year’s Eve 2025, capping a nearly decade-long run that turned a small-town monster mystery into a global phenomenon. But while the two-hour-plus closer delivered spectacle—Vecna’s defeat, Eleven’s ambiguous sacrifice, and a nostalgic basement D&D epilogue—it’s the quiet handling of one key relationship that has fans seething months later.

Robin Buckley (Maya Hawke) and Vickie (Amybeth McNulty) emerged as a genuine highlight in an otherwise divisive Season 5. Introduced in Season 4 as Robin’s awkward crush, Vickie became an official couple early in the final season, providing one of the few uplifting threads amid the military quarantines, Upside Down rifts, and high-stakes battles. Their dynamic—nervous flirting, shared secrets about the supernatural, and tender moments like stolen kisses—offered fresh queer representation that felt authentic to the show’s ’80s setting and Robin’s journey of self-acceptance.

Yet by the finale’s flash-forward epilogue, set 18 months after the world-saving chaos, Vickie is nowhere to be seen. Robin, now at Smith College studying feminism, reunites with old friends Steve, Nancy, and Jonathan atop a radio station. In a casual aside, she hints at past tensions, suggesting Vickie was “overbearing” or that distance played a role in their split. No on-screen breakup, no emotional farewell—just an offhand implication that the romance fizzled.

Creators Matt and Ross Duffer addressed the backlash in post-finale interviews, explaining the choice as realistic. “Most high school relationships don’t survive college,” Matt told outlets like Entertainment Weekly. Ross added that the epilogue focused on core legacy characters, leaving newer additions like Vickie intentionally ambiguous to let fans decide. They emphasized that not every pairing needed a tidy bow—life, especially post-trauma, is messy.

But for many viewers, the handling felt like a betrayal. Screen Rant called it a “disappointing ending” for a duo that was “a highlight of the uneven season,” pointing to the show’s chronic issue: too many characters, too little time. By Season 5, the ensemble had ballooned—core kids grown into teens, returning allies, military antagonists, and side players like Vickie—leaving some arcs sidelined. Robin and Vickie’s story, built partially off-screen between seasons, got minimal development in the final run before being quietly discarded.

Fan reaction has been swift and vocal. Reddit threads and social media erupted with disappointment, accusing the writers of lazy queer storytelling. “They gave us hope, then yanked it away without even a scene,” one user wrote on r/StrangerThings. Others noted the contrast with straight couples: Jonathan and Nancy received a poignant breakup conversation, Mike and Eleven’s bond carried emotional weight even in ambiguity, and Lucas and Max ended up together definitively. Yet Robin and Vickie? Erased without fanfare.

The criticism ties into broader gripes about Season 5. Review bombing hit hard after the penultimate episode’s Will Byers coming-out scene, dropping audience scores on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes. Some backlash veered into bad-faith territory—complaints about “woke” elements—but legitimate frustrations centered on rushed resolutions, overexplained dialogue, and a perceived lack of stakes (no major hero deaths despite buildup). The finale avoided bloodbaths, prioritizing character bonds over shock value, but that caution extended to sidelining promising new dynamics.

Vickie herself had grown from a quirky side character to an active participant: learning the Upside Down truth, helping rescue Max, and joining the fight against Vecna and the Mind Flayer. Her integration felt earned, mirroring how earlier seasons folded in allies like Murray or Erica. Yet her absence in the epilogue—while Holly Wheeler and a new kid pick up the D&D torch—underscored the overcrowding. The Duffers have defended the choices as necessary for closure, allowing the group to “move on” from Hawkins’ horrors.

Still, the decision stings for fans invested in representation. Robin’s arc—from closeted band geek in Season 3 to confident queer woman—culminated in a relationship that promised longevity. Instead, it mirrored real-world challenges: geography, growth, incompatibility. The Duffers framed it as bittersweet realism, akin to Jonathan and Nancy’s split. But without on-screen payoff, it landed flat for many.

The broader finale divided audiences. Supporters praised the emotional core—friendships enduring, nostalgia in the basement finale mirroring Season 1—and the avoidance of a cheap “everyone dies” twist. Critics slammed plot holes (military loose ends, underused Mind Flayer), Eleven’s off-screen fate, and the sense that the show played it safe after years of bold horror.

Robin and Vickie’s fate became a flashpoint symbolizing those flaws. In a series built on found family and unlikely bonds conquering evil, quietly dissolving one of its freshest pairings felt like a missed opportunity. The Duffers wanted ambiguity for interpretation—did distance doom them, or did trauma strain the connection?—but many fans saw only erasure.

As Stranger Things enters legacy status—with spin-offs in development and cultural impact intact—the Robin-Vickie storyline serves as a reminder: even beloved shows struggle with sprawling casts and satisfying every thread. The relationship that gave Season 5 heart ended not with a bang, but with silence. Whether that’s poignant realism or narrative cop-out depends on who you ask. For now, fans are left debating what could have been.