Introduction: A Turn-Based Triumph
The release of Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 on April 24, 2025, has sent shockwaves through the gaming industry, not just for its stunning visuals and innovative gameplay, but for its undeniable commercial success. Developed by French studio Sandfall Interactive, this turn-based RPG sold 500,000 copies on its first day and surpassed 1 million sales within three days, a milestone that excludes players accessing it via Xbox Game Pass. These figures have directly challenged the narrative pushed by some industry giants, notably Square Enix, that turn-based games lack market appeal in a landscape dominated by action-oriented titles. With Clair Obscur earning critical acclaim and fan adoration, it’s time to explore how this game has dismantled the “turn-based doesn’t sell” myth and what it means for the future of RPGs.
The Turn-Based Debate: Square Enix’s Stance
For years, Square Enix, a titan in the RPG space with its Final Fantasy series, has leaned away from traditional turn-based combat. Recent entries like Final Fantasy XV and Final Fantasy XVI have embraced real-time action systems, a shift driven by the belief that modern audiences prefer faster-paced gameplay over the slower, strategic nature of turn-based mechanics. This pivot has been controversial among fans, many of whom grew up with the turn-based roots of classics like Final Fantasy VII and IX. Square Enix’s leadership, including Naoki Yoshida, producer of Final Fantasy XIV and XVI, has often argued that turn-based combat doesn’t resonate with today’s broader gaming audience, prioritizing action to chase mainstream success. However, this approach has yielded mixed results—while Final Fantasy XV sold well, its combat received criticism for lacking depth, and Final Fantasy XVI’s action-heavy focus alienated some longtime fans, despite its polish.
This narrative—that turn-based games are a relic of the past—has been echoed by other major studios, creating a chilling effect on the genre. Large developers have increasingly shied away from turn-based RPGs, fearing they won’t compete with the high-octane action titles dominating sales charts. Yet, smaller studios like Atlus, with its Persona series, and Larian Studios, with Baldur’s Gate 3, have quietly proven otherwise, maintaining turn-based systems while achieving critical and commercial success. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 takes this defiance to a new level, directly confronting the industry’s assumptions with hard data and undeniable quality.
Clair Obscur’s Explosive Launch
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, developed by a core team of just 33 people at Sandfall Interactive, launched to staggering success. On its first day, the game sold 500,000 copies across platforms, a figure that doesn’t account for additional players accessing it through Xbox Game Pass, where it was available on day one. By April 27, 2025, the game had surpassed 1 million sales, a milestone announced by publisher Kepler Interactive. On Steam, it reached a concurrent player peak of over 70,000, making it the second best-selling game at the time, trailing only The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered, which surprise-launched two days earlier. These numbers are particularly impressive given the game’s competition and the modest size of its development team, many of whom are Ubisoft veterans seeking creative freedom outside the constraints of telemetry-driven, corporate game design.
The game’s critical reception has been equally stellar, with an aggregate score of 91 on both Metacritic and OpenCritic, earning tags like “Universal Acclaim” and “Mighty.” It currently holds a user rating of 9.7 on Metacritic, one of the highest ever recorded, reflecting widespread fan approval. Reviews have praised its haunting narrative, innovative combat, and breathtaking visuals, powered by Unreal Engine 5. The game’s ability to blend turn-based mechanics with real-time elements—like dodging, parrying, and free-aim counters—has been lauded as a fresh evolution of the genre, drawing comparisons to Persona and Sekiro while carving out its own identity.
What Makes Clair Obscur Stand Out?
Set in a dark fantasy world inspired by Belle Époque France, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 follows a group of heroes on a mission to defeat the Paintress, a godlike entity who paints a number on a monolith each year, erasing everyone of that age from existence. This year, the number is 33, and the stakes are higher than ever as the expedition seeks to break the cycle of death. The narrative, which explores themes of mortality, loss, and perseverance, has resonated deeply with players, bolstered by a star-studded voice cast including Charlie Cox, Jennifer English, and Andy Serkis. The game’s 35-hour runtime is tightly paced, avoiding the bloat often seen in larger RPGs, and its focus on character-driven storytelling has earned it praise as a “somber but hopeful journey.”
The combat system, described by Sandfall as an “evolution of JRPGs,” combines turn-based strategy with real-time mechanics, requiring players to actively dodge, parry, and counter enemy attacks. Each character in the party has a distinct role—such as a scythe-wielding card dealer who manages light-dark phases or a late-game character who adopts a Devil May Cry-style grading system—ensuring that battles remain varied and engaging. The game’s difficulty ramps up over time, introducing creative enemy patterns and status effects that demand strategic party composition and mastery of mechanics. This blend of accessibility and depth has made Clair Obscur appealing to both turn-based purists and players who might typically prefer action RPGs.
Visually, the game is a masterpiece, leveraging Unreal Engine 5 to create a world that feels both historical and fantastical. From warped versions of Parisian landmarks like the Eiffel Tower to eerie forests and abandoned mansions, the environments are as much a character as the expeditioners themselves. The soundtrack, blending haunting vocals with orchestral and rock elements, enhances the game’s emotional weight, drawing comparisons to the evocative scores of NieR. This combination of style, substance, and innovation has positioned Clair Obscur as a serious contender for 2025’s Game of the Year, especially with potential delays to titles like GTA VI.
Debunking the “Turn-Based Doesn’t Sell” Myth
The success of Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 directly contradicts the narrative that turn-based games lack commercial viability. Its sales figures—1 million copies in three days—rival those of major AAA titles, and its high user ratings suggest a broad appeal that transcends niche audiences. This isn’t an isolated case; other turn-based RPGs have also thrived in recent years. The Octopath Traveler series, developed by Square Enix, has sold over 5 million copies across its two entries, proving that there’s a substantial market for turn-based games when executed well. Similarly, Persona 5 and Baldur’s Gate 3 have achieved massive success while staying true to their turn-based roots, with the latter earning numerous Game of the Year awards in 2023.
So why has Square Enix been so reluctant to embrace turn-based mechanics? One theory is that the company is chasing trends, attempting to emulate the success of action-heavy franchises like God of War or The Witcher. However, this approach has led to design decisions—like the inclusion of Ubisoft-style towers in Final Fantasy VII Rebirth—that feel out of place and driven by market data rather than creative vision. In contrast, Clair Obscur’s smaller team was able to focus on a clear, passionate vision, unburdened by the corporate pressures that often stifle innovation at larger studios. The game’s success demonstrates that players aren’t rejecting turn-based combat—they’re rejecting poorly executed games, regardless of genre.
Industry Implications: A Wake-Up Call
The triumph of Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 has broader implications for the gaming industry, particularly for how AAA studios approach game development. First, it highlights the potential of smaller, more focused teams to create high-quality games without the massive budgets of industry giants. Sandfall Interactive’s lean development model allowed for agility and creativity, resulting in a game that feels both polished and personal. This stands in stark contrast to the struggles of larger publishers like Ubisoft, which, despite thousands of employees, have faced criticism for inconsistent quality in recent releases like Star Wars Outlaws. Clair Obscur suggests that the future of AAA gaming might lie in smaller, more passionate teams who prioritize vision over telemetry-driven design.
Second, the game’s success is a wake-up call for studios like Square Enix to reconsider their dismissal of turn-based mechanics. Fans have clearly shown a hunger for well-crafted turn-based RPGs, and Clair Obscur proves that these games can compete with action titles in both sales and critical acclaim. While Square Enix has the resources to push graphical boundaries, as seen in Final Fantasy XVI, it could benefit from revisiting the turn-based roots that made the series a household name. The popularity of Clair Obscur also underscores the importance of listening to fans rather than assuming what they want—a lesson Square Enix might take to heart after seeing the backlash to its recent design choices.
Community Reaction and Future Prospects
The gaming community has rallied around Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, with posts on X reflecting a mix of excitement and vindication. Fans have praised the game’s combat, art style, and story, often citing it as proof that turn-based RPGs can thrive in the modern era. Some have directly called out Square Enix, arguing that Clair Obscur’s success exposes the company’s missteps in abandoning the genre. Others have highlighted the irony that Square Enix’s own Octopath Traveler series, which is turn-based, has sold millions, suggesting the company already had evidence of the genre’s viability.
Looking ahead, Clair Obscur’s success could pave the way for more turn-based RPGs from both indie and AAA developers. Sandfall Interactive has already secured a deal for a movie adaptation, signaling the game’s cultural impact. If the studio announces DLC or a sequel, it’s likely to be met with eager anticipation. For Square Enix, the game’s performance might prompt a reevaluation of its approach to Final Fantasy XVII, potentially leading to a hybrid system that balances turn-based and action elements to satisfy both old and new fans. More broadly, Clair Obscur has redefined the potential for turn-based games, showing that with the right execution, they can not only sell but dominate the conversation.
Conclusion: A New Standard for RPGs
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 has done more than just succeed—it has rewritten the rules for what turn-based RPGs can achieve. By selling 1 million copies in three days, earning near-perfect reviews, and captivating players with its innovative combat and heartfelt story, the game has dismantled the myth that turn-based games can’t sell. It stands as a testament to the power of passion-driven development, proving that a small team with a clear vision can outshine even the biggest industry players. For Square Enix and the “turn-based doesn’t sell” crowd, Clair Obscur is a resounding rebuttal, a reminder that players crave quality and authenticity over trend-chasing. As the gaming world continues to buzz about this groundbreaking RPG, one thing is clear: turn-based games are here to stay, and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is leading the charge—dive in and see what all the fuss is about!
got
