He wielded a massive oak club against moonshiners and mobsters, becoming a Southern legend immortalized on the big screen. But after a midnight call, his wife slumps d3ad in their car from shotgun blasts – and now, investigators drop a bombshell: the hero himself pulled the trigger.
This isn’t a gritty sequel to his biopic. It’s the shattering reexamination of Sheriff Buford Pusser, accused 58 years later of murdering Pauline in a staged ambush. What dark secret fueled the betrayal behind the badge? And how did new forensics unravel a town’s cherished myth?
Discover the truth that’s rewriting history. Click here:
In the moonlit backroads of McNairy County, Tennessee, where cornfields whisper secrets and neon-lit juke joints once hummed with vice, Buford Hayse Pusser stood as a towering symbol of justice. At 6-foot-6 and 250 pounds, the former pro wrestler turned sheriff wielded a hickory club like a scepter, smashing Dixie Mafia operations—moonshine stills, gambling dens, and brothels—with a zeal that made him a folk hero. Elected in 1964 at age 27, Pusser’s crusade against crime in this rural corner of West Tennessee earned him scars, enemies, and a legend cemented by the 1973 film Walking Tall, which grossed $23 million, and its 2004 Dwayne Johnson-led remake. But on August 12, 1967, his myth was pierced by tragedy: his wife, Pauline Mullins Pusser, was gunned down in a roadside ambush, a case long blamed on mob vengeance. Fifty-eight years later, a shocking reinvestigation has turned the hero into the villain, with Tennessee authorities accusing Pusser himself of orchestrating her murder to mask personal demons and financial desperation.
The Ambush That Shaped a Legend
The 1967 ambush is McNairy County lore. At 2 a.m., a radio call lured Pusser to a supposed disturbance near Guys, a speck of a town. Pauline, 33, a former Chicago nightclub singer who’d traded sequins for a life as Buford’s bookkeeper and confidante, insisted on joining him. Their Ford Mustang rolled down State Highway 22, past the silhouette of New Hope Methodist Church, when a black Cadillac allegedly roared up. Two shotgun blasts shattered the night: one slug tore through Pauline’s face, killing her instantly; another grazed Buford’s jaw, leaving him bloodied but alive. He stumbled from the wreckage, radioing for help as deputies swarmed. The official story—backed by Pusser’s testimony and a 1968 coroner’s inquest—pinned it on the State Line Mob, a Dixie Mafia faction led by Carl “Towhead” White, a bootlegger Pusser had jailed months earlier. No arrests followed; the Cadillac vanished, and the case went cold, fueling decades of speculation about mob hitmen or crooked cops.
A Hero’s Rise, a Man’s Struggles
Pusser’s life began humbly. Born December 12, 1937, in Finger, Tennessee, to a grocery clerk and a seamstress, he grew up scrappy, wrestling hogs before hitting the pro circuit as “Buford the Bull” in Chicago. A 1962 return to McNairy landed him a job as a constable, then sheriff, on a platform of cleaning up vice. His methods were brutal: he demolished 87 stills in two years, survived eight shootings, and earned 14 scars, including a knife wound from a 1965 raid. Supporters hailed him as a “John Wayne with a badge”; critics, including local attorney Lloyd Tatum, called him a “bully with a stick,” alleging he strong-armed innocents. Financially, Pusser struggled. His $300-a-month sheriff’s salary barely covered medical bills from his injuries, and Pauline’s $100 weekly bookkeeping couldn’t bridge the gap. By 1967, the couple owed $12,000 on their Adamsville home, with Buford dodging creditors and dipping into county funds for “expenses,” per 1966 audit leaks later uncovered.
A Marriage Under Strain
The marriage wasn’t idyllic. Pauline, a striking brunette with a sultry alto, had dazzled Chicago’s lounge scene before meeting Buford in 1959. They wed in 1960, raising daughter Dwana, then 6, in a modest brick house. Friends described Pauline as Buford’s anchor, soothing his temper and typing his reports. But 1966 brought strain: Buford’s late-night patrols doubled, rumors swirled of affairs with a diner waitress, and Pauline’s diary—unearthed in 2023—hinted at fights over his drinking and “reckless spending.” A March 1967 entry read: “He’s not the man I married—scares me sometimes.” Pauline confided to her sister, June Mullins, about Buford’s threats to “leave no trace” if she ever left him. June, now 78, told TBI in 2022: “She loved him, but feared his rage.”
The Cold Case That Cracked Open
The 2022 reinvestigation began with a tip. A retired deputy, speaking anonymously to the Jackson Sun under the alias “John Doe,” claimed Buford confessed in 1973—post-Walking Tall fame—that “Pauline wasn’t supposed to be there.” The TBI, spurred by a $50,000 cold-case grant, exhumed Pauline’s body in April 2024. Forensic pathologist Dr. Emily Chen found discrepancies: the fatal slug’s trajectory suggested a close-range shot from a seated position, not a speeding car. Ballistic tests on a 12-gauge Mossberg—linked to Pusser’s personal arsenal via a 1967 pawn shop receipt—matched the pellet spread. A reenactment using 3D laser mapping showed the shooter’s angle aligned with Buford’s driver’s seat, not an external vehicle. Most damning: a 2023 search of Pusser’s former home, now a rental, uncovered a hidden floorboard cache with a bloodstained glove—Pauline’s DNA confirmed—bearing Buford’s partial print.
Motive and Means
Investigators point to a crumbling marriage and money woes. Pauline’s $100,000 life insurance policy, doubled in June 1967, named Buford sole beneficiary. Court records show he cashed it weeks after her death, paying off debts and buying a new Chevy Impala. TBI uncovered a 1966 letter from Buford to a Memphis loan shark, promising “big moves” to settle $8,000 in gambling debts. Witnesses, including ex-deputy Carl Pusser (Buford’s cousin), testified in closed 2024 hearings that Buford bragged about “staging a hit” to dodge alimony and secure Dwana’s custody. The Cadillac? A red herring, possibly driven by accomplice Jimmy Ray “JR” Hicks, a small-time crook who vanished in 1968 and whose sister, Lila Hicks, told TBI in 2023: “JR said Buford paid him $500 to drive and shut up.”
Flaws in the Original Probe
The original probe, led by Sheriff James Dickey after Buford recused himself, was riddled with holes. Deputies ignored Pauline’s diary, dismissed June’s pleas, and never tested Buford’s Mossberg, stored in evidence until 1970. A 1967 witness, gas station clerk Ellie Mae Turner, reported seeing Buford alone near the church at 1:45 a.m., but her statement was buried. “McNairy protected its hero,” said TBI Agent Laura Hodge, who spearheaded the reinvestigation. Pusser’s post-ambush fame—$1 million in movie deals, speaking gigs at $5,000 a pop—silenced doubters. He resigned in 1970, citing health, and died August 21, 1974, when his Corvette crashed at 100 mph on Highway 45. Official ruling: accident. Conspiracy buffs, citing his 1973 FBI tip naming mob bosses, still cry foul.
A Community Divided
The fallout is seismic. Dwana Pusser Garrison, now 64 and a retired nurse in Selmer, collapsed at the 2025 presser, sobbing: “Daddy was no killer—she was his world.” She runs the Buford Pusser Museum, which shuttered temporarily in September amid vandalism—spray-painted “Murderer” on its sign. Pauline’s family, led by June, filed a 2024 wrongful-death suit against Pusser’s estate, seeking $2 million for “decades of deception.” Locals split: Adamsville Mayor David Leckner defends Buford as a “flawed savior”; barbershop chatter calls it betrayal. “He cleaned our streets but dirtied his soul,” said retiree Hank Thompson, 71.
Media and Psychological Fallout
Media feasts on the wreckage. A 2026 Netflix doc, The Fallen Giant, promises unseen TBI tapes. Podcasts like Southern Fried True Crime hit 3 million downloads with episodes dissecting Buford’s “Jekyll-and-Hyde” psyche. Dr. Michael Stone, a forensic psychiatrist, labels him a “narcissistic vigilante,” driven by control and fame-lust. “His club wasn’t just for crooks—it was his identity,” Stone told Psychology Today. Critics question the TBI’s timing: Why now, post-mortem? Some smell politics—Davidson’s 2026 DA reelection bid looms. Others laud forensic leaps: laser mapping, DNA preservation, and AI-enhanced audio from 1967 radio logs pinpointing Buford’s voice pre-shooting.
A Legacy in Ruins
McNairy County grapples with its icon’s fall. The museum’s fate hangs on a November council vote; some push to rebrand it a “crime history” site. Pauline’s grave, adorned with fresh daisies, draws quiet mourners. June, at a September vigil, clutched a photo of her sister singing: “She deserved truth, not a movie.” Buford’s legacy—once towering like his oak club—crumbles under scrutiny. No charges can touch him now, but the verdict of history stings: a hero’s badge, tarnished by blood, leaves a town to reckon with its tallest tale.
