Law & Order: Organized Crime has a new tagline for season 5, but the claim it makes is a lie. Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5 has been highly anticipated, with no release date in sight for quite some time. However, Peacock recently released the first Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5 teaser, which includes a short trailer, promotional images, a release date, a brief description of season 5’s premise, and a new tagline. Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5 will premiere exclusively on Peacock on April 17, 2025, with two new episodes.

Despite Law & Order: Organized Crime‘s surprising movie to Peacock for season 5, the upcoming season will surely be the best yet, especially after the explosive season 4 finale that leaves Elliot Stabler’s brother’s fate hanging by a thread. According to Variety, Elliot Stabler will “put everything on the line to protect the vulnerable and fight for justice” while investigating domestic terrorism. The most fascinating aspect regarding Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5’s upcoming season involves the show’s new tagline—a surprising choice, given Elliot Stabler’s complicated history.

Law & Order: Organized Crime Season 5’s New Tagline Explained

“In Stabler We Trust”

Law & Order: Organized Crime‘s new tagline reads, “In Stabler We Trust,” suggesting that the fate of justice rests in Detective Elliot Stabler’s hands. The epithet suggests that he is his brother’s only hope after Joe Jr. becomes trapped with the devious criminal Julian Emery in season 4, episode 13, “Stabler’s Lament.” The new slogan could also refer to upcoming events that the season will portray now that Stabler is entirely responsible for justice.

Variety reveals that “a crime family [is] intent on repaying Stabler for the injury he did them in Rome,” while he gets involved with “cross-border smuggling” and “high-tech domestic terrorism.” “In Stabler We Trust” also suggests that no matter what Elliot Stabler encounters, he is trusted to do the right thing, bring about justice, and save the day. However, this is a fascinating decision because Stabler has not always been trustworthy.

Stabler Is Committed To Delivering Justice, But He Isn’t Exactly Trustworthy

Elliot Stabler Notoriously Left Olivia Benson & SVU Without Saying Anything

Elliot Stabler has always pursued justice, but he is not a trustworthy person because of his fallout with Olivia Benson. Stabler never tells Benson that he will retire instead of attending mandated counseling. It is difficult to forget the sheer heartbreak on Benson’s face when Cragen tells her about Stabler’s retirement—one of the many Law & Order scenes that illustrate why Benson and Stabler should not be together. Stabler is bold in the pursuit of justice, but the way he leaves things with Benson proves he can also be cowardly and untrustworthy.

Stabler is first and foremost a family man, and he would do anything to protect those he loves, even if it involves lying or morally questionable actions.

Furthermore, while Stabler is usually reliable regarding justice, he has twisted the system to his benefit if the perpetrators involved are friends or family. Stabler is, first and foremost, a family man, and he would do anything to protect those he loves, even if it involves lying or morally questionable actions. He is by no means a perfect man, and his flaws might come back to bite him in Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5, especially if the crime family understands Elliot Stabler and his weaknesses.

Stabler Not Being Trustworthy Makes Him An Interesting Hero

Stabler Has Always Been A Complex Character

Elliot Stabler might not be the most trusting person, but that is part of why he is such a compelling character. Stabler has been flawed from the beginning, and his return to the Law & Order universe complicates him more as he navigates his new position while grieving his wife. Stabler is fiercely loving and protective, but he has failed his loved ones before. He has a concerning track record as a police officer with a high count of shooting incidents—which is why Cragen forces him to either retire or go to mandated counseling.

When Stabler returns to the NYPD under the Organized Crime Control Bureau, he has trouble adjusting for several reasons—most notably, in the aftermath of his wife’s untimely death. He also has difficulty because police officers can no longer get away with problematic interrogation methods—something Stabler is notorious for in Law & Order: Special Victims Unit. Stabler can be violent and opinionated, which often lands him in hot water. Despite all his flaws, Stabler is an incredible character—they make him more interesting. His upcoming arc in Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5 will surely contribute significantly to his character arc.