Hailey Bieber Reels as Justin’s Like on Selena Gomez’s New Pics Sparks Drama

The saga of Justin Bieber, Hailey Bieber, and Selena Gomez, a love triangle that has captivated fans for over a decade, erupted into fresh controversy in April 2025 when reports surfaced that Justin liked and then unliked an Instagram post featuring Selena Gomez and her fiancé, Benny Blanco. The alleged social media gesture, reported by fan pages on X, has sparked claims that Hailey Bieber is “shocked” and that the Biebers’ marriage is under strain. Amplified by viral YouTube videos and X posts, the rumor has reignited debates about Justin’s lingering feelings for his ex and the dynamics of his relationship with Hailey. But is there truth to the claim of Hailey’s shock, and what does this incident reveal about the ongoing drama? Let’s unpack the rumor, examine the context of Justin’s actions, and explore why this social media storm has gripped the public.

The Bieber-Gomez Saga: A Decade of Drama

Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez’s on-again, off-again relationship from 2010 to 2018 was a cultural phenomenon, dubbed “Jelena” by fans. Their high-profile romance, marked by breakups and reconciliations, ended for good in March 2018. Just months later, Justin married Hailey Baldwin in a September 2018 courthouse ceremony, followed by a larger celebration in 2019. The couple welcomed their son, Jack Blues, in August 2024. Selena, meanwhile, found love with music producer Benny Blanco, announcing their engagement in December 2024.

Despite the passage of time, the narrative of a feud between Hailey and Selena has persisted, fueled by social media speculation and fan loyalty. Hailey has faced accusations of “stealing” Justin from Selena, despite her 2022 Call Her Daddy podcast clarification that there was no overlap in their relationships. Both women have publicly supported each other—Selena posed with Hailey at the 2019 Academy Museum Gala, and Hailey liked Selena’s engagement announcement post in 2024—yet fans continue to pit them against each other. The latest rumor, claiming Justin’s Instagram activity shocked Hailey, has added fuel to this long-burning fire.

The Rumor: Did Justin’s Like Shock Hailey?

The claim that Hailey Bieber was “shocked” when Justin liked Selena Gomez’s new Instagram photos emerged on April 6, 2025, via an X fan page post. The post alleged that Justin briefly liked and then unliked a Complex Instagram carousel featuring Selena and Benny Blanco, including a photo of them kissing. The images, originally shared by Selena with the caption “a few memories,” celebrated her engagement and Only Murders in the Building success. The fan page’s claim, picked up by outlets like Yahoo, suggested Justin’s action hinted at unresolved feelings, causing distress for Hailey amid rumors of marital strife.

However, the evidence is shaky. No verified screenshot confirms Justin’s like, and the claim relies on fan speculation rather than concrete proof. Web searches and X posts show no direct statement from Hailey expressing shock or distress. Her recent public activities, including a Coachella appearance with Justin on April 9, 2025, and an ice cream date in Los Angeles, suggest the couple is maintaining a united front. Justin, for his part, has not addressed the rumor, focusing instead on promoting his SKYLRK brand and sharing cryptic Instagram posts about personal growth.

The rumor appears to be an exaggeration, likely fueled by Justin’s history of social media activity tied to Selena. In early April 2025, he posted a meme featuring Gollum from The Lord of the Rings, captioned “Girls on social media when they get engaged,” which fans interpreted as a dig at Selena’s engagement. The timing of the alleged like, days later, amplified speculation. Yet, without confirmation, the narrative of Hailey’s “shock” remains a product of fan-driven drama and clickbait headlines.

Contextualizing Justin’s Social Media Behavior

Justin Bieber’s Instagram activity has been under intense scrutiny in 2025, with fans and media dissecting his posts for signs of personal turmoil. Since January, concerns about his mental and physical health have surfaced, with reports describing him as “manic,” “not sleeping,” and “hardly eating.” His April 2025 social media spree, including reposting memes and sharing a shirtless livestream, alarmed fans, who noted his “hollow-eyed” appearance. A confrontation with paparazzi in Palm Springs on April 9, where he accused photographers of prioritizing money over humanity, further fueled perceptions of distress.

The alleged like on Selena’s post fits this pattern of erratic online behavior. Fans on X speculated that Justin’s actions reflect lingering feelings for Selena, with comments like “He’s been married for 8 years and has a child, but still shading his ex” and “Karma is real” after her engagement. Others suggested the like was accidental, part of Justin’s “rapid-fire” posting habits. Hailey’s own Instagram activity has drawn attention—she reportedly unfollowed Justin in March 2025, later calling it a “glitch” on TikTok—adding to rumors of marital tension.

Hailey’s history with Selena-related rumors complicates the narrative. In March 2025, she was accused of liking a TikTok video mocking Selena and Benny’s Interview magazine shoot, a claim her representative denied as “fabricated.” Her liking of Selena’s engagement post in December 2024 was seen as a gesture of goodwill, yet fans continue to interpret her actions as “shady.” The lack of direct evidence for Hailey’s “shock” suggests the rumor is an extension of this ongoing cycle of speculation.

The Snow White Connection: A Tangential Drama

The Snow White remake, starring Rachel Zegler as Snow White and Gal Gadot as the Evil Queen, provides a tangential link to the Bieber-Gomez drama. Zegler, a friend of Selena’s, faced controversy for her political comments, which reportedly strained her relationship with Gadot, a former IDF soldier. Snow White’s $400–$500 million loss has been partly attributed to Zegler’s polarizing presence, mirroring the scrutiny Selena faces. While unrelated to Justin’s Instagram activity, the film’s cultural fallout—marked by debates over representation and activism—echoes the social media storms surrounding the Biebers and Gomez.

The Bigger Picture: Fan Culture and Media Amplification

The rumor of Hailey’s shock reflects the power of fan culture and social media in shaping celebrity narratives. The “Jelena” fandom, still active years after Justin and Selena’s split, fuels speculation about their interactions, often casting Hailey as the antagonist. X posts like “That baby’s first words will be Selena Gomez” and “He loves her Mexicanly” illustrate the fervor driving these stories. Media outlets, from Yahoo to Daily Mail, amplify these narratives, capitalizing on the public’s fascination with the Bieber-Gomez saga.

Hailey has addressed this dynamic directly, calling the feud narrative “completely made-up” on Bloomberg’s The Circuit in 2023. She emphasized that the drama is not about “pitting two women against each other” but about “vile, disgusting hatred” from fabricated stories. Selena, too, has urged fans to stop the hate, noting in 2023 that Hailey received death threats over the rumored feud. Despite their efforts, the cycle persists, with each social media interaction scrutinized for hidden meaning.

The Impact on the Biebers’ Marriage

Rumors of marital strife between Justin and Hailey have intensified in 2025, with incidents like their mutual Instagram unfollows and Justin’s erratic behavior cited as evidence. Sources report the couple is navigating challenges, including disagreements over religion and lifestyle, but their public appearances—Coachella, a spa day, an ice cream date—suggest they are working through issues. The birth of their son, Jack, has reportedly strengthened their bond, though Justin’s health concerns remain a focal point.

The Selena rumor adds pressure but lacks the substance to confirm a crisis. Hailey’s resilience, seen in her dismissal of similar rumors and her focus on Rhode skincare, indicates she is accustomed to navigating such drama. Justin’s cryptic posts about “inauthenticity” and “letting go” hint at personal struggles, but they don’t directly implicate Selena or Hailey.

Why This Rumor Resonates

The claim that Hailey Bieber was shocked by Justin’s like on Selena Gomez’s photos has captivated audiences because it taps into a decade-long narrative of love, heartbreak, and rivalry. The $400–$500 million Snow White flop, with its own cultural controversies, mirrors the scrutiny faced by these stars, amplifying the drama. While the rumor lacks evidence, it reflects real tensions—fan-driven speculation, media amplification, and the challenges of celebrity in a digital age. As Justin, Hailey, and Selena move forward, this social media storm proves that old flames can still spark new fires—Why This Social Media Move Is Igniting a Hollywood Firestorm!